6 Incogni Alternatives for 2026 (Free and Paid)

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Full affiliate disclosure.

Incogni is the data removal service people arrive at first, mostly because it is marketed by the team behind Surfshark and priced as an easy add-on: around $8 a month on annual billing, nearly hands-off once started. Its distinguishing approach is legal rather than technical. You grant power-of-attorney-style representation, and your opt-outs are filed as formal demands under privacy law instead of consumer requests, so a broker that ignores one is dealing with a representative rather than an individual.

What it does not include is just as clear from the published plans: no meaningful free tier beyond a scan-only preview, no identity theft insurance, and no family bundle at the time of writing. Coverage skews toward the large US and UK brokers. The dashboard does show which sites have removed your data, which refused and which are still processing, which is more transparency than most of this category offers.

So the reasons people look for an alternative are specific: they want to see the machinery working before paying, they want insurance attached to the same bill, they need to cover four family members, or they are already paying for a VPN and resent a second subscription for what feels like the same cleanup. Below is what to use instead, ordered by which of those is your actual reason. Our full data removal services comparison covers the wider field, including the vendors ranked here.

The short answer

Pick	Service	Price	Why
Best if you want proof first	PrivacyHawk	Free tier; $74.99/yr Premium	Full scan plus 10 real opt-outs a month before you pay anything
Best free tier for reconnaissance	Optery	Free; paid from about $99/yr	Continuous scanning, screenshots of what it found, and self-serve opt-out steps
Best if you want a human to check	DeleteMe	$129/yr per person	Removals verified by people rather than fired off as emails; the longest track record
Best if you already pay for a VPN	Surfshark One+	Bundled tier	Incogni-powered removal inside the VPN subscription you may already have
Cheapest possible	Manual opt-outs	Free	Every broker has an opt-out route; the cost is your time and the repetition
Best if you want pure automation	Incogni	About $8/mo billed annually	Legal-representation route with a dashboard that separates removed from refused

1. PrivacyHawk — best if you want to see it work before you pay

The structural difference between PrivacyHawk and Incogni is what happens before money changes hands. PrivacyHawk’s free tier runs a full privacy scan that shows exactly which brokers hold your profile, and it includes 10 real opt-outs a month. That is not a teaser screen; it is enough work to judge whether the service is competent, and it directly answers the question that stops most people from subscribing to anything in this category.

On price it also comes in lower. Premium runs $74.99 a year — about $6.25 a month — for unlimited removals and monthly re-scans, which undercuts Incogni’s roughly $8 a month on the same annual basis. The vendor states a 30 to 90 day window per broker, the same range every legitimate service in this market works to, so the timeline is not where the difference lies.

The tier that matters for anyone leaving Incogni over insurance is Platinum at $124.99 a year: it adds SSN monitoring, change-of-address protection, dark web alerts and up to $1 million in identity theft insurance. The honest weakness is that those alerts sit behind Platinum rather than Premium, so the mid tier does not get them. Family tiers cover four members, which is the answer if the reason you are switching is that Incogni had no family bundle.

2. Optery — the most useful free tier in the category

If your goal is reconnaissance rather than removal, Optery’s free plan does more of it than anything else here. It scans brokers continuously, shows you screenshots of what it actually found rather than a list of names, and hands you step-by-step instructions to opt out yourself at no cost. For someone who suspects they are listed but has never seen proof, that evidence is worth more than a subscription at this stage.

Paid tiers start at roughly $99 a year and take over the filing, with higher tiers adding more frequent sweeps and coverage of more obscure brokers. The catch is arithmetic: once you want automated removals, Optery’s pricing overlaps PrivacyHawk’s Premium while including fewer of the extras — no insurance, no unsubscribe tool, no SSN monitoring. Use the free tier to find out what is out there, then decide whether continuous exposure screenshotting is the feature you actually value.

3. DeleteMe — best if you want a person checking the removals

DeleteMe is the veteran of this market and the name most people search for first. Its signature difference from Incogni is human verification: removals are checked by people rather than only dispatched as automated requests, and the recurring report tells you which sites dropped your data, which refused and when the next sweep happens. In a category where the hard part is proving a negative, that review step is the product.

Standard pricing is $129 a year for one person — frequently discounted, but still the premium option here — and it covers the major people-search brokers thoroughly. The trade-offs are the mirror image of Incogni’s: it is single-purpose with no insurance and no unsubscribe tool, monitoring focuses on broker re-listings, there is no free tier, and the price climbs quickly for families. If you want the longest-running name with accountability built into the process, the premium is defensible.

4. Surfshark One+ — check the bill you already pay

This is less an alternative than a way of not buying one. Surfshark’s One+ tier bundles Incogni-powered data removal with the VPN, antivirus and alerting into a single subscription. If you already pay for a Surfshark plan, the removal capability may be sitting in a tier you have not looked at, and upgrading is usually cheaper than adding a standalone service.

What it will not give you is depth. There is no identity theft insurance, and removal is the accessory rather than the product, so the reporting and the legal escalation are not at the level of a standalone subscription. For anyone shopping for a VPN anyway the bundle math is hard to beat; for someone whose only requirement is aggressive removal across obscure brokers, a dedicated service still does more. Our Surfshark review covers what the One+ tier does and does not include.

5. Doing it yourself — free, and not as unrealistic as it sounds

Every legitimate broker publishes an opt-out route, and the 30 to 90 day processing window applies whether a service files the request or you do. If a free scan shows your data on a handful of sites, submitting those opt-outs yourself is a couple of evenings of work and costs nothing. This is the correct answer for a small footprint, and it is worth doing even if you later subscribe, because it tells you how the process behaves.

The reason people stop is repetition, not difficulty. Brokers re-list profiles, so removal is not a one-off task; doing it quarterly across dozens of sites, remembering which ones refused, and chasing the ones that ignored you is exactly the labour a subscription removes. If your scan returns dozens of entries, the arithmetic flips quickly — and if it returns three, paying $75 to $130 a year to file three forms is hard to justify.

6. The case for staying with Incogni

The legal-representation model is the part the alternatives do not replicate. Incogni treats your opt-outs as formal demands under privacy law rather than polite consumer requests, which changes the calculation for a broker weighing whether to ignore you. Combined with a dashboard that separates removed from refused from still-processing, that is a coherent product for someone who wants to delegate the whole problem and not think about it again.

The honest limits are the ones in its own plan structure: no meaningful free tier, no identity theft insurance, and no family bundle at the time of writing. If none of those three matter to you, switching buys very little — the annual saving against PrivacyHawk Premium is real but small, and the removal work is broadly similar across legitimate providers. The people who gain most from switching are those who need insurance, those covering a family, and those who want to see a scan before committing.

Switching without paying twice

1. Run a free scan before cancelling anything. PrivacyHawk’s free scan and Optery’s free plan both show the broker list. Knowing the size of the problem decides whether you need a subscription at all.
2. Check whether your VPN already includes removal. A Surfshark One+ upgrade is often cheaper than a new standalone service, and it is the most commonly missed option.
3. Look at the renewal date, not the monthly price. These services are annual. Cancelling mid-term rarely refunds, so line the switch up with the renewal rather than the calendar.
4. Expect the timeline to restart. A new provider files its own requests, so the 30 to 90 day window begins again. Do not cancel the old service on day one if a removal is already mid-process.
5. Keep the confirmation emails. If a broker re-lists you, the record of a prior removal is what makes the second request easier — with either provider.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a free alternative to Incogni?

Two of them give you something real for nothing. PrivacyHawk’s free tier runs a full privacy scan showing which brokers hold your profile and includes 10 actual opt-outs per month, which is enough to judge the machinery before paying. Optery’s free plan scans continuously, shows screenshots of what it found, and walks you through opting out yourself. Neither replaces a paid plan for volume, but both tell you whether you have a problem worth paying to fix.

What is cheaper than Incogni?

PrivacyHawk Premium at $74.99 a year works out to about $6.25 a month, against roughly $8 a month for Incogni on annual billing. The gap is small in absolute terms, but the comparison is not only about price: PrivacyHawk also exposes a working free tier, so you can verify coverage before either subscription starts.

Which Incogni alternative includes identity theft insurance?

PrivacyHawk Platinum at $124.99 a year is the one on this list that bundles up to $1 million in identity theft insurance, along with SSN monitoring, change-of-address protection and dark web alerts. Incogni does not include identity theft insurance, and neither does DeleteMe or Optery at their standard tiers. If insurance is the requirement, it narrows the field to one.

Does Incogni use a different legal approach from the others?

Yes. Incogni has you grant power-of-attorney-style representation and treats your opt-outs as formal demands under privacy law rather than consumer requests, so a broker that ignores the request is dealing with a legal representative. The practical effect shows up in how refusals are handled rather than in the removal list itself.

Which is better for a family, Incogni or PrivacyHawk?

PrivacyHawk, on the published plans. Its family tiers cover four members, while Incogni had no family bundle at the time of writing. That is a packaging difference rather than a protection difference — the underlying removal work is similar — but four individual subscriptions cost considerably more than one family tier almost anywhere in this category.

Can I remove my data from brokers myself for free?

Yes, and for a small number of brokers it is the rational choice. Every legitimate broker publishes an opt-out route, and the 30 to 90 day processing window applies whether a service files the request or you do. What you are buying with a subscription is repetition: brokers re-list profiles, so the work is not a one-off, and doing it quarterly across dozens of sites is where most people stop.